Apparently there’s a rule that you’re not supposed to try out a new recipe on company when you’re entertaining. That means it’s definitely not a good idea to do it when you’re presenting a recipe in front of students.
Rules were made to be broken…or something.
Case in point.
I made these Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshakes for the first time in front of two groups of 15 people when I taught a Food Styling Class with Joy a few weeks ago. THANK HEAVENS it all worked out.
When you pair vanilla ice cream, pumpkin puree, BOURBON, brown sugar and spices, what really could go wrong?
For starters, you could totally drop some ice cream on the floor and almost turn on the blender when you’re not quite ready for it. You could also put an extra shot of bourbon in by accident. And you could show a group of eager students how messy you really are when it comes to working in the kitchen.
Yep. All of this totally happened… If anything, our students learned that I’m just a regular gal who happens to love both food and making messes in the kitchen.
And we’re off!
Ingredient shot! This was me showing our students at our Food Styling Class how I set up an ingredient shot.
I’ll tell you more about the class soon. I promise. I’m still putting away dishes from that class. Whew!
Oh! Ice cream. There’s a bunch of it in this recipe. Details….
Here’s an overview of me putting everything in the blender. You have no idea how good this smells.
The bourbon in this recipe is totally optional. It sure gives the milkshake a boost, though.
And here we have the milk. It wouldn’t be a milkshake if there wasn’t milk, right?
Blend it up. Pour it out. Blurry action shot. Just go with it!
Whipped cream just magically appears. How convenient!
We get some fresh nutmeg grated for topping.
A dollop of whipped cream. A pinch of nutmeg. What are we missing?
Gingersnaps! And a sun drenched table.
ENJOY!
serves 4
recipe adapted from Sunset Magazine
- 2 cartons (14 oz. each) vanilla ice cream, softened
- 1 cup canned pumpkin
- 1/2 cup milk
- 1/4 cup bourbon
- 1/4 cup packed light brown sugar
- 1/4 tsp. freshly ground nutmeg
- 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger
- 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
- sweetened whipped cream (optional)
- gingersnaps for garnish
Whirl ice cream, pumpkin, milk, bourbon, sugar and spices in a blender until smooth. Pour milkshake into 4 tall glasses and top each with a dollop of whipped cream, a pinch of nutmeg and a gingersnap cookie. Serve with straws.
































2007 - 2012 shutterbean, All Rights Reserved.
50 Comments
say somethingThese look so good. I’m from the bourbon state so these would be a hit around here – yum!
Ha, I probably would drop some ice cream too… Looks amazing nonetheless!
LOVE this! Bourbon always makes it better.
This sounds AMAZING! I’ll have to make it sans bourbon for now, but at least it’s for a good reason.
I often try new recipes for company. As long as it’s from a trusted source (like a great food blog), I say go for it! I’ve never had a major fail.
I love the way the contents of the glass look ombre! I love the creamy swirl of cream/ice cream near the top. Looks amazing – you had me at nutmeg and pumpkin.
Looks heavenly! Thanks for sharing!
Just when I’d stopped fantasizing about that damn milkshake, here it is again. I need it in my mouth and life ASAP.
TWSS, obviously.
Oh my word. This looks incredible.
I was there! The milkshakes are delicious (although very decadent), and you totally rocked the demo. You seemed cool and pulled together (and didn’t make that much of a mess). Thanks for a great class!
Thank YOU for coming. I absolutely LOVED meeting you, Martine!! Good times Good times.
I’m not going to lie, sometimes I think of you when I’m writing blog posts. The chalkboard contact paper last week (because it’s black and white and organized and crafty) and this weeks’s Thanksgiving timeline checklist (because its a geeky crazy long organizing list for the holiday): http://nourishandpreserve.wordpress.com/2012/11/08/thanksgiving-plan-for-a-relatively-stress-free-t-day/
Hope you enjoy it!
Sigh. Now I am even sadder that I missed the food styling class.
This looks like fall-heaven in a glass. Yum!
Oh my, this looks so incredibly good.
It IS incredibly good.
THIS IS TOO MUCH. TOO MUCH. Bourbon. Pumpkin. Everything is right in the world.
I’ll put this on my weekend buckkkkket.
Thanks for being rad Tracy Shutterbean.
aww. Thanks for being an awesome reader!! Bourbon or bust!
Lady, you speak my language. I looove bourbon in a milkshake.
You had me at bourbon.
Can’t wait to try this! Even the husband is excited. You have ground ginger listed twice. Did I miss something?
Nope. You spotted my error. THANK YOU!!!!!!!!
oh no you didn’t. but you totally did, and the can of pumpkin in the pantry is about to be put to use
WOWZA! Pumpkin, bourbon and ice cream … now that is a dessert to serve not only guests but myself!!
DUDE!!!
MUST MAKE THIS ASAP! What a fantastic idea Tracy!!
You make me tipsy.
doesn’t take much!
holy moly milkshake heaven!!!
Exactly.
I like how you say “whirl” everything in the blender. That’s way better than “mix”.
Perfect idea for this upcoming warm fall weekend, the best of summer and fall together!
that photo of the milk being poured is amazing- cant stop staring for some reason… this milkshake is EVERYTHING.
oh mama. I am literally salivating
If you ask me, an extra shot of bourbon is always an excellent choice. Wish I could’ve attended your class and topped it off with this milkshake!
Delish, delish. And, I’m all for breaking the rules!
Bourbon and pumpkin is my new favorite combo!!! I can’t believe I never thought of it before seeing that they are two of my favorite things separately. I’m making this recipe this thanksgiving…
Trackbacks & Pings
[...] bestie and her baby. Huge fall leaves all over the sidewalks. Cold weather cocktails like these and this. Getting better at standing up for myself. The storm brewing outside my window right [...]
[...] Autumn makes me all a bit giddy, changing leaves, knitwear, hot toddies, sheltering from the rain in the corner of a little pub… I have found autumn giddiness in a milkshake form! Over on Shutterbean.com there is a recipe for a Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshake. [...]
[...] polenta with extra parmesan and sausage and caramelized onions. And I’m gonna have to try the pumpkin bourbon milkshake. [...]
[...] Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshakes [...]
[...] cocktail: (because you can have two desserts on Thanksgiving) Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshakes from [...]
[...] lifted the recipe from one of our favorite food bloggers, Tracy Benjamin of Shutterbean. And then a few tweaks were made. (Spoiler alert: I doubled the [...]
[...] Inspiration from around the web | curated by Love and Lemons. These pumpkin bourbon milkshakes they posted look pretty [...]
[...] Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshakes [...]
[...] It has three ingredients, is perfect for those who are new to bourbon, and for those who aren’t into just straight bourbon. It calls for Ginger Beer and we found Angry Orchard’s Apple Ginger Cider that we loved in this drink. Also, if you’re like me, now that you have a bottle of bourbon sitting around, you can cook things like this Vanilla Bourbon Baked Acorn Squash, these Bourbon Pudding with Candied Pecans, and this Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshake! [...]
[...] P.S. I didn’t forget about the recipe for these pumpkin, bourbon, ginger milkshakes. The link is right HERE!) [...]
[...] Six Degrees LA made my Pumpkin Bourbon Milkshakes. [...]
[...] to a Facebook friend, I’m enjoying one of these tonight. It’s really good, but I think next time I make them I’ll substitute the [...]
[...] there. I had a fabulous chocolate croissant at brunch with Elizabeth and Amy the other day. I drank a pumpkin milkshake WITH BOURBON IN IT with my book club last night. I’ve indulged in fresh baked whoopie pies from a coworker and I [...]