Are you sitting down? Good. So, I baked these banana doughnuts to share with you. That’s right, baked. I spared a few calories by baking the doughnuts but don’t worry I made up for it on the back end. Peanut butter frosting sounds pretty amazing right? What could possibly make it better?
Cue the flashing lights, throw confetti in the air, hug the person next to you because Browned Butter has made its way into this peanut butter frosting. Check out those browned butter bits! That’s totally not vanilla bean, it’s butter!
A banana bread like doughnut gets glazed with a sweet/savory peanut butter & browned butter frosting. Watch out, you’re getting drool on your keyboard!
And we’re off!
Get your ingredients together.
Dry ingredients in a bowl.
Prep your wet ingredients & spray your doughnut pan with cooking spray.
Dry meets wet! Stir stir stir.
Fill up your pan with batter. Off to the oven it goes.
Let’s make some browned butter! As if peanut butter frosting wasn’t enough…
Hello peanut butter.
Melt the peanut butter in the microwave. Get that browned butter off the stove.
Peanut Butter + Browned Butter = True Love.
Now add in your confectioner’s sugar. 1/4 cup at a time.
Oh look who decided to show up!
Let the doughnuts cool and dunk them in the peanut butter frosting.
Keep it up. This recipe makes 12 total! Watch out.
Take a break.
Eat a doughnut. You deserve it.
Banana Doughnuts with Peanut Butter Frosting
Makes 12
(recipe heavily adapted from Rachael Ray Magazine)
- 1 1/4 cups flour
- 2 teaspoons baking powder
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 1/2 teaspoons ground cinnamon
- 3/4 cup granulated sugar
- 2 eggs, at room temperature
- 1 1/4 cups mashed ripe bananas (3 bananas)
- 2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
- 1/2 cup vegetable oil
- 1/2 cup smooth peanut butter
- 2 tablespoons salted butter
- 1/2 cup confectioner’s sugar
- hot water
Preheat the oven to 350°. Grease 2 nonstick, 6-count doughnut pans. In a large bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder, salt and cinnamon. In a small bowl, whisk together the granulated sugar, eggs, mashed bananas, vanilla and the oil. Stir the wet ingredients into the dry until just combined. Spoon the batter about three-quarters full into the prepared pans. Bake until golden and a toothpick inserted comes out dry, 12 to 15 minutes; let cool completely on a rack.
Put the salted butter in a small pan and heat over medium-high heat until melted and nicely browned, about 4-5 minutes. Place the peanut butter in a small bowl and microwave until melted & smooth (about 15-30 seconds). Add the browned butter to the peanut butter and slowly stir in the confectioner’s sugar. If your frosting is too thick, add a tablespoon of hot water into the mix. Dip the bottom (smooth edge) of your doughnut into the peanut butter frosting and repeat until done!
Shutterbean Notes:
-if you don’t have a doughnut pan, make muffins! The cooking time should be pretty similar, give or take 5 minutes (more).



































2007 - 2012 shutterbean, All Rights Reserved.
59 Comments
say somethingReading this right before bed = I am so going to dream about donuts again tonight!
What a great combination of flavours and the fruit makes them totally healthy
you are an evil kitchen genius. I may give in to Sophie’s badgering (honey badgering?) for a doughnut pan.
how did you get into my head and steal my dougnutty dreams?! i am going to make these and start wearing my maternity jeans again and when people ask me when i’m due it’ll be all. your. fault
this is perfect. as i’ve been looking for something that I can make my officemates
plus…peanut butter!!! omigosh
DD
Holy crap. I need these in my life.
I have all these wonderfully spotted bananas, I NOW HAVE A PURPOSE FOR THEM.
Thanks you Tracy!
Oh wow! They look amazing!
Yeah man, I have the mini donut pan, and now I need the large marge donut pan! These look dreamy.
Oh man, these look so good! I can’t wait to try them
i want a donut pan! i was eyeing one the other day on a sale rack…
I had just decided to cut back on my sugar consumption, and then these showed up….Is the texture more like banana bread?
it’s sorta like banana bread- a little more airy!
So it sounds like you definitely recommend these donut pans? I’ve been interested in them lately but I don’t think I’ve ever tried a baked donut, so I’m hesitant.
These donuts look amazing!
Yes! I recommend them. They’re pretty fun to use. I like them because I can give Cooper a donut (without frosting) and he thinks he’s having a real treat.
A doughnut pan!? You were giving your sister-in-law a hard time for having a scone pan and you’ve gotcherself a doughnut pan?!!
I kid, I kid. It look like a fun kitchen tool
XOXOXOXOX,
Alli
Don’t put me on blast!!! This is a good way to make donuts that aren’t fried. Totes different. TOTES different.
I see the appeal. You are excused :*
Also, totes gonna make these with my muffin tin. Browned butter makes me cray cray. It’s so divine! Woo!
That sound is me fainting from what looks like one of the best recipes ever. Bravo!
I can’t believe that these are homemade!
I just drooled all over myself!!
Shut. The. Front. Door.
No donut pan here (if I brought one into this apartment my partner might plotz), but I bet these would make pretty sweet cupcakes. I think they’re going on the list.
Before I left the house I looked at my banana’s all spotted with little black dots and thought I better make a bunch of banana bread or something! You must be reading my mind!
I however don’t have a donut pan… any suggestions?
I now see the suggestion… didn’t finish reading.
Wow! Double wow! Triple wow!
…Susan
This is awesome. So awesome. Sounds amazing. I really like the note at the end of using a muffin tin. I don’t have a doughnut pan. I totally need one now. YAYAYAYAY!
Oops. Looks like the oil measurement is missing. …Susan
Thanks for catching that! Fixed!
Wahhh, Elvis donuts!! These look/sound crazy good. I would put chocolate chips in the batter because it’s a reflex that I’ve given up fighting. If butter is God’s Gold, what is browned butter? I feel like this is important.
Oooh good question!!!! Lemme think about that. Hmmmm.
What an awesome flavor combo. They look majorly delicious! And the donut baking pan-I kind of need one! Awesome.
Chocolate mini chips or bacon on top might just put these over the top. *heads out door to buy bananas*
These doughnuts look, well… bananas!! I just bought a doughnut pan, and have yet to make any. This might be the first recipe I try out. And @beth, mini chocolate chips would put these right over the top!!
Chocolate chips….wow! I was thinking of crumbled bacon on top…..How do you feel about that?
Bacon is allllllllllllllllllllllways appropriate.
This is so amazing! Really making my mouth water…I wont be passing by Krispy cremes after tasting this
…
well shoot lady. these are putting me over the top. I even have a boat load of nanners waiting to be used up.
but, um, what to do if I don’t have the schnazy pan???
You can use a muffin pan (i added it to the note!)
Woah, these look amazing! Have avoided making doughnuts because of the frying involved but finally a recipe for baked doughnuts! And who knew you could buy pans for them! Tracy you are a baking genius.
These look orgasmically delicious and as soon as I am back in the states and back in a real kitchen I’m going to make them for myself and eat them for breakfast. I mean it’s bananas and peanut butter right? That’s healthy.
Totes healthy
Where are you living now?
Paris actually. I’m working in a pastry shop for six months as an intern. My apartment may be large by Paris standards but my kitchen certainly is not. I don’t even have a real oven. I have a microwave oven that also can become an oven. I didn’t even realize those existed but apparently they’re popular here. Truthfully though, transformers only work in the movies, it’s not like I could put a turkey in this thing…
Oh and the french totally don’t understand peanut butter like we do. You can’t even find it at most of the little grocery stores they have here.
They are in the oven right now. I think that this is what heaven must smell like. Peanut butter frosting is divine!!! Thanks for sharing! This Tuesday just a little more special….
Hooray! I’m so glad you tried it out! ENJOY!
I looked at this post at the WORST possible time. Totally eating my computer right now.
OMG!! These look fantastic!! There goes my diet…again!
I’ve never made donuts! I think this may be the perfect way to introduce myself to them. That looks fantastic!!
Did someone say banana and donuts in the same sentence? Ok I’m getting a mini donut pan… pronto! This looks amazing and I can already taste it. Yum! I’m not into peanut butter like this but I’d totally try it just to say I did. Thanks for sharing!
Made these with my Mom this last weekend. 2nd ever donuts baked. SO GOOD
Rich, just like I love my food. Mmmmm.
Trackbacks & Pings
[...] Recipe by Shutterbean [...]
[...] curious) and have been testing out recipes. The pictured doughnut above was Shutterbean’s banana doughnuts with peanut butter frosting. More banana bread than doughnut but still pretty tasty. This weekend, I tried out King [...]
[...] Makes 12 – really close to this Shutter Bean recipe [...]
[...] shutterbean banana doughnuts with peanut butter frosting (!!) [...]
[...] have a board on Pinterest dedicated to just doughnut recipes. One of my favorite recipes is this banana doughnut with peanut butter glaze from [...]
[...] Microformatting by EasyRecipe2.2.6Source: Original recipe from Rachael Ray Magazine. Adapted from Shutterbean.var linkwithin_site_id=138883;var linkwithin_div_class="linkwithin_hook";Related Posts:Eggless [...]
[...] from Shutterbean’s Banana Donuts Yield: 6 donuts Active Time: 15 minutes Total Time: 30 [...]
[...] Recipe adapted from Shutterbean [...]
[...] And that banana cupcake I scarfed down at Ad Hoc had me wondering if I could make a baked banana doughnut…. [...]